It has often been quoted as the key to political, economic and societal success. The book is original, crisply written, and extremely clever in how it teases important interpretations out of apparently innocuous data. Think again, in foreign policy, winter 19992000, pp. Why governments target civil society and what can be done in. David rieff, the false dawn of civil society, the nation, feb 22 1999. There are deep patterns common to transitional countries. How are nongovernmental organizations and their partners. The renaissance of interest in civil society draws strength from its european roots, which are traceable to the late eighteenth century and early nineteenth century development of the distinction between civil society and the state au1 keane, 1998. Civil society as salvation civil society is cast in a heroic role in a wide variety of works that deal.
Carothers is a leading authority on international support for democracy, human rights, governance, the rule of law, and civil society. Civil society has become something of a buzzword in the field of middle east studies and in political science in general over the past decade, espe. Civil society aid and democracy promotion critically. Carothers the idea that civil society inherently represents the public good is wrong in two other ways as well. According to the world bank 2010, civil society refers to the wide array of nongovernment.
Her conclusions, that civil society protest may not be as much of a problem for democracy even in highly mobilized polities like bolivia as a lack of faith in elections, offer new and vital insights. Citizen activism is considered as any individual action with social consequences, and much of it involves collective activity. When i visited tunis and started talking to people, several things immediately felt familiar. In 1989, as the united states government and various private organizations began to send people and money into central europe to help with the democratic transition, historian jacques barzun published a brief essay in societyin which he asked just what these. He has written extensively on transitions from authoritarian rule, political. Pdf in the name of civil society download full pdf.
His goal is the healthy one of sparking discussion among both scholars and those who are practitioners of democracygovernment officials, civil society activists, or professionals who work in the field of democracy promotion. Civil society and the lawyers movement of pakistan law. A comparative view from thomas carothers thomas carothers, senior vice president for studies at the carnegie endowment for international peace in washington, d. Solidarity foundations and ingos why shrinking civil society space matters in international development and humanitarian action. I argue that, otherwise, the lawyers movement could not have headed the movement that eventually led to the restoration of democracy.
In preparation for a 7 november 2019 dutch parliamentary debate on strengthening international civil society, carothers spoke to representatives from the dutch ministry of foreign affairs and the breed mensenrechten overleg, a network of dutch human rights and development organisations that promotes attention to human rights in dutch foreign policy. That civil society organizations receiving foreign funding are accountable to external. Thomas carothers on strengthening civil society nhc. In 1989, as the united states government and various private organizations began to send people and money into central europe to help with the democratic transition, historian jacques barzun published a brief essay in societyin which he asked just what these missionaries proposed to teach. Civil society has become a buzzword in the rhetoric of a wide circle of classes, from political scientists to presidents. In recent years the united states and many other international donors have embraced civil society aid as a key tool of democracy promotion.
While democracy development can stagnate, there is no reason why civil society development should wait for democratic institutions to consolidate. Vice president for studies, carnegie endowment for international peace. Civil society aid and democracy promotion washington, d. Perhaps the most obvious role that civil society can play in security matters is as a public watchdog, checking that security sector actors are performing their tasks both within the remits assigned to them and within the general direction in which society is developing. He is the author of six critically acclaimed books as well as many articles in prominent journals and newspapers. Singh argued for an expansive role for civil society in sdg 16 implementation, calling upon civil society actors to take the lead in official policymaking, planning, implementation, budgeting. Foreshadowing the concerns expressed by the global alliance of civil society leaders, civicus, in 2014, john clark suggests shifts in tactics and argues that civil society is becoming less relevant with a loss of citizen support. Drawing on extensive field research and years of handson experience, thomas carothers examines democracyaid programs relating to elections, political parties, governmental reform, rule of law, civil society, independent media, labor unions, decentralization, and other elements of what he describes as the democracy template that. Moreover, there is an understating of how the state can spoil prospects for democratization.
Restrictions on civil society around the world and u. Thomas carothers aiding democracy abroad the learning. Citizen activism and civil society oxford scholarship. The situation can move quickly from a mushrooming of civic groups to heated debates over. United states institute of peace tom lantos human rights. Why governments target civil society and what can be. Drawing on extensive field research and years of handson experience, thomas carothers examines democracyaid programs relating to elections, political parties, governmental reform, rule of law, civil society, independent media, labor unions, decentralization, and other elements of what he describes as the democracy template that policymakers. Julie hearn, foreign aid, democratisation and civil society in africa. The term civil society can be traced through the works of cicero and other romans to the ancient greek philosophers, although in classical usage civil society was equated with the state.
The long term approach of the promotion of democracy would foster a new confidence in the united states and eventually provide a safer and better world community. A common element of governments efforts to close space for civil society is measures restricting foreign support. Zalerts allow you to be notified by email about the availability of new books according to your search query. Thomas carothers t he world of international development assistance is brimming with broad concepts that sound widely appealing and essentially uncontroversial.
At the same time, in some contexts, civil society has acquired new spaces and enabling environments. Institute of peace, testified before the tom lantos human rights commission on march 21, 2017 on responding to the global threat of closing civic space. Thomas carothers, the end of the transition paradigm, journal of. Jan 01, 2002 thomas carothers is vice president for studies at the carnegie endowment for international peace in washington, d. Duncan hiscock the role of civil society in security sector. Download pdf in the name of civil society book full free. Civil society, definitions and approaches john keane. Civil society aid and democracy promotionis edited by marina ottaway and thomas carothers 2000. The legitimacy of civil society then becomes an issue. Our overall aim is to push back against growing restrictions to civil society. Carothers has also worked extensively with the open society.
Some of these concepts pertain to specific areas of aid programming, such as civil society, the rule of law, governance and decentralisation. He serves as vice president for studies at the carnegie endowment for international peace, where he founded and currently directs. Whether it stimulates democracy or reinforces authoritarianism. This chapter contains a more indepth discussion of who citizen activists are, how they pursue change, and what outsiders can do to help. Ngos, political protest, and civil society by carew boulding.
Why governments target civil society and what can be done. Although many civic activists may feel they speak for the public good, the public interest is a highly contested domain. In the name of civil society available for download and read online in other formats. Responding to the global threat of closing civic space. They support thousands of ngos around the world in the name of civil society development, investing in these organizations high hopes for fostering democratic participation and values. Exploring the impact of transnational civil society on the. Thomas carothers is an expert on international democracy support, democratization, and u. One of the most recent is an excellent piece written by thomas carothers civil society, in foreign policy, no 117, winter 19992000. During the revolutionary period 1750 1850, the traditional language of civil society societas.
He has worked on democracy assistance projects for many organizations and carried out extensive field research on aid efforts around the world. Open society foundations, thomas carothers, carnegie endowment for international. Observers who focus too much on elections have failed to grasp the maturation of iranian civil society, even as hardliners have come to dominate the. The closing space for civil society, in other words, is a global problem. He is the author of many works on democracy promotion, including aiding democracy abroad. Rather, carnegie endowment scholar thomas carothers notes that it is part of a larger tectonic shift that gained momentum in the middle of. The learning curve 1999, and is the coeditor with marina ottaway of funding virtue. Thomas carothers critiques programs for funding civil. Thomas carothers and saskia brechenmacher, closing space. The concept of civil society is a recent invention. Examining civil society legitimacy carnegie endowment. Carothers lesson for the aid community was to not expect a sequence to unfold in.
The main space is dedicated to civil society groups, their aid and democracy promotion in various countries, and how democracy promotion is in the interests of the united states. This cited by count includes citations to the following articles in scholar. He serves as vice president for studies at the carnegie endowment for international peace, where he founded and currently directs the democracy and rule of law program. Civil society in turmoil, civil society in development. The paper is aimed at civil society organisations, national governments, international and regional organisations and other key actors concerned with icts and their impact on international and regional security. Government harassment of independent organizations is as old as the state system itself, but this wave of targeting has a twentyfirstcentury twist.
Civil society in fall 2010 comparative perspective 5. Specifically, as citizens find new ways to organize, assemble, and express themselves through the use of affordable. Foreign assistance congressional research service r44858 version 5 updated 1 introduction congress has long expressed interest in supporting democratic governance and related rights in other countries as a means of projecting american values, enhancing u. Duncan hiscock the role of civil society in security. He has also taught at several universities in the united states and europe, including central european university, the johns hopkins school of advanced international studies, and nuffield college, oxford, where he is a seni. Drawing on extensive field research and years of handson experience, thomas carothers examines democracyaid programs relating to elections, political parties, governmental reform, rule of law, civil society, independent media, labor unions, decentralization, and other elements of what he describes as the democracy template that policymakers and aid officials apply around the world. Civil society organizations csos around the world are confronting ever stricter limitations on. Civil society aid and democracy promotion critically examines this burgeoning field. Civil society is under stress globally as dozens of governments across multiple regions are reducing space for independent civil society organizations, restricting or prohibiting international support for civic groups, and propagating governmentcontrolled nongovernmental organizations. The problem of closing space for civil society is neither new nor is it a shortterm phenomenon. Aiding democracy abroad by thomas carothers overdrive. Describing what was at stake, carothers explained that civic space is seen as a dangerous thing for some regimes. Thomas carothers has written a timely and important essay that deserves wide attention. Responses congressional research service summary civil society organizations csos around the world are confronting ever stricter limitations on their ability to operate, a phenomenon often referred to closing space for civil society work.
In a widely cited paper for the carnegie endowment for international peace, carothers and brechenmacher 2014 argue that these trends are likely to continue. This type of activity has grown exponentially across the developing world, and is driven by several factors. However, the concept of civil society has been charged with far more expectations than it can possibly achieve. In the case of pakistan, civil society actors were vital in helping the judiciary become politicized and in linking the lawyers movement to the larger cause of democratization. Examining civil society legitimacy carnegie endowment for. His work has focused on the areas of civil society development, political party assistance. For the purpose of the paper we define civil society as a social sphere separate from both the state and the market and made up of non. This fresh criticism is very healthy, long awaited and welcome. Closing space and fragility united states institute of peace. Thomas carothers is vice president for studies at the carnegie endowment for international peace in washington, d. Initiative for civil society the funders initiative for civil society fics brings together private philanthropy from around the world, to help ensure that civic space is free and open, with engaged citizen participation that is free of restriction from governments.
Pdf peace and democratic society download full pdf. Clean air is a public good, but so are low energy costs. A search query can be a title of the book, a name of the author, isbn or anything else. Another work on civil society calledfunding virtue. Thomas carothers aiding democracy abroad the learning curve. Pdf in the name of civil society download full pdf book. Such observations from a diverse set of scholars leads one to ask. Authors this paper was written by julian oram, consultant and deborah doane, funders. Carnegie endowment for international peace, 2000, pp.
146 676 1660 944 1117 659 714 237 483 245 1230 1679 1075 763 418 14 896 356 316 861 799 1264 1281 1018 758 143 1036 505 380 1285 819 1188 931 1447 212 1396 639 874 450 924 404 1048 1016 585